This would actually not a problem with this build; Sir John de Keith d

Re: ? Comyn spouse from Malise

Concerning Comyn daughter who had been spouse away from Malise off Strathearn, I’d theorized within the 2005 one to she was indeed Margaret, defined as wife from Sir John de- Keith (select copy off post less than) who was 2ndly e are given for the reason that blog post: the fresh new spouse Emma I would recommend try of some other family members, rather than mom of one’s second Earl Malise.

Scots Peerage, sandwich _Comyn, Earl regarding Buchan_ , claims simply, ‘Malise, Earl from Strathearn, had a spouse Emma, into the 1261-1267, whoever surname is unfamiliar ‘[SP II:256, alludes to Cal. of Docs., i. 2383, 2451]. a bit prior to 1270, to ensure that their widow (Margaret) could have been “available” sometime after Emma.

This is without a doubt a conjecture; it can feel the advantage of coping with a known relationship anywhere between Muriel Keith and you may Reginald ce Cheyne. More relevant paperwork do naturally be welcome.

The new membership within the Scots Peerage concerning the group of Keith states of Sir John de Keith (d. ca. 1270) which he are said to keeps hitched Comyn, earl out of Buchan . So it character, of one’s unclear (“considered have been”) diversity, is now able to be corrected in line with the following dispensation, dated at the Fondi towards fourteen The month of january 1378/9::

‘ Reg Aven 215, 50 To your bishop out-of Moray. Professors in order to distribute Reginald Cheyn, donzel, and you can Murielle, damselle, d de- Keth, off Moray and you will Aberdeen dioceses, in the obstacle in order to relationships due to the third and you can 4th amounts of consanguinity. Fondi, 19 Kal. Feb., anno 1. SRO Vat. Trans., iv, zero. 46. ‘

Muriel Keith, the future 2nd wife out of Robert Stewart, first Duke out of Albany (d. 1420), was developed to get married Reginald le Cheyne, child regarding Sir Reginald ce Cheyne from the their partner (just like the their first husband), Helen from Strathearn. When you are discover known openings on the origins away from Muriel Keith, she and you can Reginald ce Cheyne perform share an origin regarding Comyns. not, this is also faraway to require a great dispensation in the event the Muriel try a beneficial-great-great grandd Comyn, Earl regarding Buchan (d. 1233), that will function as the situation when the is why daughter.

dos. Reginald ce Cheyne is actually an effective-grandson of Marjory Comyn, child from Alexander Comyn, Earl off Buchan (d. 1290), young man away from William Comyn in the list above. Their child is Malise, Earl off Strathearn away from 1312 so you can their demise into the 1328 , and you can pops out of Reginald.

ca. 1270), are same as Marjory Comyn, and you can married 2ndly to help you Malise, Earl regarding Strathearn (d. 1312). This would indicate the newest parentage a€?said to has been’ that Margaret, spouse regarding Sir John de- Keith, is of you to age group: she’d not have already been the new d Comyn, Earl off Buchan, but instead off his child Alexander. There’s absolutely no evidence you to definitely Earl Malise and you may Marjory Comyn was basically married far just before 1275: as Lindsay wrote,

There is you to definitely discernable basis about what the partnership ranging from Reginald le Cheyne and you can Muriel Keith would have existed: in the event the Margaret Comyn, partner away from Sir John de- Keith (d

‘ Brand new spouse of this earl, from the 1275, is called Marjory, as we comprehend the attesting term out-of Zero. curriculum vitae., which will be stated of the Wyntoun, Guide VIII. chap. vi., having become another aunt away from John Comyn, Earl of Buchan, who discussed with respect to Earl Malise the marriage payment a lot more than said [old at London area, April twenty six, 1293 to own his daughter Matilda and you may Robert de- Tony, young man out-of Ralph].’

Alexander Comyn = E de Quincy Elizabeth regarding Buchan We __________________I________________ We III step one) Sir John = Marjory = 2) Malise de- Keith I (als We Elizabeth out-of Strathearn . Balinese kvinnlig 1270 We Margaret) I d. 1312 _____________I__ ___I__________________________ We We I We We We Sir William Bernard Malise Gilbert Robert Maud de- Keith de- Keith Elizabeth away from = Robert d. bef 1293 Strathearn; d. 1328 de- Tony We ______I_______________________ We We We We Sir Edward Malise Mary Helen = Isabella de Elizabeth from Strathearn = 1) Sir Reginald Synton d. california. 1343 We le Cheyne I I I = 2) Sir David I V We We de- Graham Sir William de- I We__________ Keith We We = Margaret Fraser __________________I_______ V __I_____________ I We We III We We I We Muriel + Reginald Mary Mariota Keith ce Cheyne (= Robert Stewart, Duke of Albany)